Skip to main content

If I Had Your Face: “We do not live for tomorrow.”

Have the fullest extent to life the sentence said, however, the novel If I Had Your Face had totally defined it in a different way. If I Had Your Face is the first novel written by Frances Cha, who grew up in the United States, Hong Kong and South Korea. The book is set in contemporary Seoul and revealed lots of social problems through the eyes of four girls, AraKyuriWoona and Miho. The four characters each has their own different settings, showcased through their different hardships and experiences faced while involving in different jobs and roles. I believed and would like to conclude that the unbearable trauma they had undergone in their pasts and present days, revolves around the main theme of the book: the huge disparity between the rich and poor. Nevertheless, there are also various other issues faced by the four characters. 

At first glance, Ara, a stylist who is obsessed with K-Pop boy groups, would not stand out as someone involved in juvenile violence when she was younger. Unfortunately, one serious fight near the Big House left her badly injured and even lost the ability to speak. Her parents were working and serving the Big House and that it was impossible for them to move out from the little annex on the Big House especially after they had spent all of their fortune on treating Ara's injury. “…I will arrive at the conclusion that I didn't want to walk past the site of my injury. You see, there is only one road to the Big House and there is no way to avoid it.” Through the way from returning home after three years of leaving, the readers would find out how contradicting Ara was to the Big House. Ara was guilty and could not bear to see her parents living in the small annex for the rest of their lives. Despite working her own head off, Ara is unable to afford any property in Seoul. 


Kyuri, a pretty room salon girl who had once gone through many plastic surgeries to the extent of growing an addiction to it which had caused her a pile of debts and had to work as a room salon girl to earn lots and lots of money. Room salon was a place where the men would bring their clients there to discuss business. It might seem offensive for me to say that the room salon is kind of like a brothel, but men going to that place are willing to pay a lot to have girls sit next to them for a drink and even sex. Kyuri had seen so many married men frequenting the room salon, and readers could see how hard it is for her to trust in men. The men who visit her workplace (which was known to be one of the high-class ones) usually are from chaebol family and the rich people, some of them would just pay for a sex partner, some would want girls to become their mistresses. I was shocked when it is revealed that Kyuri had a crush on Bruce, the man who had a girlfriend but always pay for sex with Kyuri. Their relationship took a turn for the worse (had was never even good to begin, she was just one out of many sex partners for him) when Kyuri tried to snoop on Bruce and her girlfriend's families gathering. Bruce felt offended and humiliated. As an act of retaliation, he punished Kyuri by reporting to the police on the dirty jobs happening at Kyuri's workplace. Readers could feel how overwhelmed Kyuri was for a long time until the police had came. She even decided to take it on her own as she believed the Madam of room salon would not let her off easily. "If they (customers) see the police here, the entire night's business will be lost and men might stay away for good. And I have no doubt that Madam will put this all on my tab. My debt will run to several tens of millions of won before the night is over. I feel like I am about to faint... Pulling myself together, I take a breath and step forward."  


Miho, a naive artist in the girls' eyes, is also the one had once mingled with the “rich gang” when she was studying in America, she even had one as her boyfriend. Miho from a poor and broken family was raised by her aunt and uncle when her parents decided to escape and abandon her. She was later sent to the Loring Center, an orphanage where she grew up there. She is talented in art and had the opportunity to get a full scholarship for her degree at the United States. While studying, she worked in Ruby's studio and met Ruby's then boyfriend Hanbin, who later became Miho's own boyfriend. Unfortunately, Ruby committed suicide which made Miho depressed and felt guilty for a long time. Miho and Hanbin returned to Seoul after their graduating and Miho began working at a new studio. She had always refused the Hanbin's offer in aiding her career such as suggesting taking advantage of his family's reputation especially when his mother already dislike her due to her lowly background. Even though Miho had always felt unconfident and insecure in their relationship, she still loves him very much and always tried hard to reach him, his level and status. However, as what Kyuri had suspected on every other menHanbin was also cheating unbeknownst to Miho. Their relationship was never equal from the get-go, as even Hanbin did not know the deepest fears of Miho and was willing to hurt her that much. 


Woona, the only married woman among them, has a story different from the others too. Besides the hot issues that the other girls had gone through, the biggest issue in Woona's story puts an emphasis on her childhood trauma. Woona had experienced a serious childhood trauma living with her grandmother who was a total “mad woman”. Her grandmother was an "expert" in verbal abuse which also caused all her children trying to escape from her, as the family was always shrouded with pressure and depression. Woona's parents had divorced early in their marriage, so she grew up with her grandmother and had to endure all those worst abuse from her grandmother until her father came to raise her back. Once she grew up, she got into a marriage and had her own mind on the idea of a "family". However, Woona was believed to have been suffering from prenatal depression as she had experienced three miscarriages. Due to the past miscarriages, she worried about having it the fourth time and did not even prepare anything for the child on her halfway into the pregnancy. She was escaping as much as she can, but this was also her expression of how much she wanted the child to be saved. From her story, we could see the author was setting a contrast on Woona’s childhood trauma and her strong desire to have her own children. And readers would believe that she will fill up all of her deficiencies from childhood through giving her love to her girl (she had assumed that it is a girl) whole-heartedly. She will be the mother that she never had to her child, filling her with unconditional love. 


The fifth girl, Sujin was the special one since she had no any self-storytelling, but readers could find out her story through AraKyuri and Miho’s storylines. Sujin had spent her childhood with Miho at the Loring Center. She was precocious and pessimistic as she knew that the Loring Center was only interested in developing the talented kids, but somehow the center also had its limitation in it. Sujin was the one who told the person in charge about the opportunity of the scholarship when she heard of it and asking the Center to help with Miho. When Miho was busy training her art skill, Sujin joined a school and became acquainted with Ara. As both of them involved with juvenile violence, Sujin felt that she should take responsibility on Ara. She wanted to be a room salon girl just like Kyuri was to earn as much as she can to make Ara and her lives much easier and better. She also followed Kyuri's steps by undergoing different plastic surgeries to have a perfect and pretty face. When Kyuri had a hard time at her room salon job, Sujin suggested her to change a new job at a plastic surgery clinic.  


Anyways, five of them were living in the same office-tel, the place where their story begins. The book shows how these five girls were working hard to find success in their lives. As what the book said, “You have to grow up with parents whose lives become better as time goes by, so you learn that you must invest effort for life to improve. But if you grow up around people who situations become worse as time goes on, then you think that you have to just live for today. And when I ask young people, What about the future? What did you do when tomorrow comes and you have spent everything already? They say they will just die.” There are the things we should think about. What happen to the girls? Why did they have to go through all of these hardships? And why is it that their lives only seem to be harder as if there is no hope at all even though they have given all they had in chasing their successes? The ending of the book sees the five girls had finally gathered together for once which kind of brings some positivity to the readers seeing as the girls' stories are full of downs. I find Kyuri's thought to herself while looking at the 3D ultrasound photo of Woona's baby interesting: "For a fleeting moment, as Sujin passes me the photograph and I hold this flimsy, curling image in my hand, I understand what it would be like to think only about tomorrow, instead of just today." The budding of a new life seems very brightly, isn’t it? However, think deeply. The beginning of a new life is not always filled with rainbows and butterflies, seeing as the new-born would be raised in a tough environment. Bright lives are only for the richer ones, isn't it? 

 

 

by Lay Foon 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

【活动回顾】初一拾五导读会:黎紫书《流俗地》

上个周末,初一拾五进行了一场线上导读会,导读书目为马华作家黎紫书近作《流俗地》。在这场导读会中,我们首先为大家简单介绍了作者及其作品《流俗地》。而后,成员嘉玲也为大家讲解了小说主角银霞的盲人设定,以及书中出现的猫和迦尼萨,同时也在银霞的经历与政治走向之间作了一个隐喻的链接。紧接着,成员秋柔、丽欢、棋薇分别就俗人、俗事、俗地、俗物为大家讲解内容,以让参与者更加了解该作品。最后,我们亦分享了彼此的读后感,也推荐大家阅读本雅明《讲故事的人》作为一个补充。以下,将附上导读会成员所制作的PPT: 最后,非常感谢大家的出席,祈愿下次还有机会再与大家见面!

从执着到释然——钟晓阳《哀伤纪》的谱成

一 部 作 品的续写或重版,究竟是对一个故事的延续还是补充呢?作家钟晓阳在 2008 年重新执笔后对自己早前已出版的一些作品进行了续写和重版,作品中有的新附书信,也有对旧作 “ 推倒重写 ” 的。当中 2014 年出版的《哀伤纪》收录了钟晓阳 1986 年的初版《哀歌》以及她 2014 年续写的《哀伤书》。与《哀歌》相隔了 28 年的《哀伤书》似是在叙说着同一个或延续的故事,然而当中的人物、情节虽与前者的设置有相似之处,仔细琢磨一番后却发现它们并不如此。   上半部《哀歌》以第一人称倒叙手法讲述了少女“我”到美国三藩市求学时与梦想成为渔夫出海的“你”从初识到相爱再分离的故事。这是一段“留不住”的故事,小说中的“你”一直为梦想做准备,即便是后来出现的“我”也无法阻止 “你”的 脚步。“我”对“你”情深至愿随“你”在海上流浪,“你”却不愿意更不忍心自己的梦想耽误了“我”的青春。直到“你”的海上捕鱼生涯开始,“我”和“你”已渐行渐远直至不再相见,昔日的情分也只能随海风而去。   准确地来说,这是一部“我”对“你”的深情剖白,富含“我”的执着以及无能为力的哀伤。 《哀歌》是一部很美的作品,诗一般的字句为作品增添美而哀伤的氛围。我并没有像“我”一样的情感经历,当中“我”对“你” 所 倾 述的话语却一字一句无不牵动着我的内心 。“我”对“你”的爱确实过分执着得让人不明白,但“我”对“你”的执迷通过钟晓阳笔下的一字一物贯彻全篇,那份爱而不得的心情怎不叫人心疼、可惜?“我”曾经努力留住“你”, 但生命 只 能 容纳海洋的 “你”却无法容纳一个小小的“我” 。 “我”也只能一直沉浸在“留不住你”和“失去你”的痛苦里,唯有依靠漫长的时间帮助淡化、治愈伤痛。最后,多年以后的“我”在明白了玫瑰的颜色是逐渐褪淡的,如同人类的命运其实也因遵循着这样的原理事实——没有事物是永存的,“我”对于爱“你”这件事情也就逐渐释然。   在下半部《哀伤书》里虽然依旧以第一人称叙述,却不再只有“我”和“你”,作品增加了许多人物和支线,人物也都被赋予了名字——金洁儿(我)、占、郑星光、蒋明经、简小汶等。小说不再是像《哀歌》一样的“情书”,更像是为《哀歌》补充、完善的故事。 《哀伤书》讲述了金洁儿的人生起伏以及与三位男 人 的情感纠葛,我们会 自然 地将金洁儿对应为《哀歌》中的“我”

《夕雾花园》读后感

《夕雾花园》这部作品因为其电影入围了各大奖项而备受瞩目,而其实这部作品除了叙述了一段美丽的史诗爱情故事,同时也揭露很多不同的题材。在这部小说之中有大量对马共的书写,但是由于我对马共的认识不多,在接下来的文章就不会有太多讨论,但是真的很推荐小伙伴们看看这部小说哦! 这个故事以一个曾经在战争之中被日军抓去当战俘的云林为主角,为了打造在拘留营死去的姐姐最喜欢的日式花园,而跑到金马伦寻找久居于此的前日本皇家庭园师中村有朋,后来两人坠入爱河的故事。这部小说精彩的地方在于它有别以往对日军的刻板印象,描写了两个看似对立的人们如何相爱,同时也展示了在战争时期不同立场的人们的面貌。 不一样的“加害者” 小说的男主角——中村有朋是一名前天皇御用的庭园设计师,在战争之前就已来到马来亚居住。身为日本人的身份使有朋时常感到痛苦、罪恶,因为出现在他生活中的人们多是在战争中被日本人伤害的人们。这让他每每面对他们的时候都感到愧疚,于是他尝试以 专心 打造属于自己的日式花园与世界隔绝,逃避自己的同胞为了“荣誉”所造成的伤害。 有朋贵为前天皇御用的庭园设计师,其家族在当时的日本也有相当高的地位。虽然后来因为一些人事问题,有朋被夺去皇家庭园设计师的身份而离开日本来到了马来亚,但是在日本侵占马来亚的时候,有朋可以说是竭尽所能去保护身边所有的人,避免他们遭受日军的迫害。因为有朋的关系,日军不会侵犯马久巴茶园,他们也不会伤害为有朋工作的工人们。有朋也因此在日据时期,尽其所能去收容当地人作为他的工人,以免他们受难于战争。麦格纳斯在战争爆发期间也有叫上云林一家,到金马伦来投靠有朋,只是云林父亲不愿投靠日本人而拒绝了。 战争结束之后,有朋的内心依然感到愧疚;他不赞同日本提议的“荣誉之战”,但也无法违抗天皇。云林说在夕雾花园里,她感觉这里和外面的世界完全隔离了,仿佛一切的痛苦不曾发生过,内心一片平静。这就是有朋建造夕雾花园的原因。他尝试打造这座平静的花园,隔离自己与外面的世界,希望能在这篇花园之中得到平静。他的内心充满对日军和战争的不满,但是尽管有再多的不服气,他却不能与天皇对抗。这样的矛盾和纠结,让有朋这个角色更加的令人心疼。 在日据时期,日本人是加害者。作为马来西亚人民的我们,自小就能从爷爷奶奶口中听到日本人如何迫害当时的马来亚华人。在他们的叙述当中,日本人就好像恶魔一样残忍而无情